British Virgin Islands

SHOWING:

901 to 950 of 6707 results
  

Sort By:

Search

Filter By:

Topics

show more show less

Jurisdictions

show more show less

Allegations

show more show less

Alameda Research Ltd. et al v. Michael Giles et al: Complaint (‘$63M Fraudulent Transfers’)

May 17, 2023
Complaint in Alameda Research Ltd., of the British Virgin Islands; West Realm Shires Inc., and West Realm Shires Services Inc., both of Delaware v. Michael Giles, Harland Group LLC, Propel Venture Partners, LLC Propel Venture Partners US Fund I, L.P., LGF II, L.P., Buckley Ventures GP, LLC Buckley Ventures, LP, Laurence Beal, Y Combinator ES20, LLC, Acrew Capital MGP, LLC Acrew Capital Fund, L.P., Homebrew Ventures III, LP, SWS Holding Company, LLC, Treasury Fund I, LP, Bain Capital Venture Fund 2019 LP, Fund I, a series of 20VC, LP, Soma Capital Fund III Partners LLC SOMA Capital Fund, III, LP, Kerr Investment Holdings Pty Ltd atf The Kerr Family Trust, The 2016 Karkal Family Trust, YCC20, L.P., Yaselleraph Finance Pty Ltd atf Yaselleraph Finance Trust, S20, a series of Chris Golda Investments, LP, Launchpad Capital Fund I LP, Motivate Ventures QP Fund I, LP, Liquid 2 Ventures Fund II, L.P., Correlation Ventures II, L.P., Adapt VC LLC, AAVCF3 LP, Basecamp Fund 201 via Alumni Ventures Group Embedded Trust, The Gardner 2008 Living Trust, Cathexis Subsidiaries GP, LLC, Cathexis Ventures LP, Craig Shindledecker, Operator Partners, LLC, Acrew Capital Fund (A), L.P., Motivate Ventures Motivate Ventures Fund I, LP, Adam Boryenace, Stuart Sopp, VentureSouq Capital SPC o/b/o VSQ SP 59 (YCS20), Jonathan Weiner, James Nichols, Peter T. Lawler Living Trust, Carol H. Duggan Revocable Living Trust, KV5 Pty Ltd a/t/f KV5 Trust, Michael Ferrari, Stanton Camp, Mike McGee, BCIP Venture Associates II, L.P., Aaron Frank, Benjamin Londergan, Jonathan Christodoro, Z Perret Trust, Paul Akhil, Fairchild Fund III, LLC, BCV 2019-MD Primary, L.P., Kamran Ansari, BCIP Venture Associates II-B, L.P., Monique Saugstad, Christopher Young, Derek Clark, Joshua Allen Slate, Justin Lovero, Tana Lawler, Tim Millar, Dena Wever, John Dwyer, Brandon Mann, David Meents, Lindsey Boerner, Brent Johnson, David Streckert, Kiara Baudoin, TI Platform NLI Venture Limited II, Torch Capital II, LP, PruVen Capital Partners Fund I, LP, Fin VC Regatta I, LP, TI Platform Fund II, LP, Thomas G. Miglis Revocable Trust, Alumni Ventures Group - Embedded Financial Trust A, Philippe Jabre, Silverstone Venture Investments Limited, EM Fund I, a series of Chris Golda Investments, LP, TriplePoint Private Venture Credit Inc., Fund 1, a Series of Not Boring Capital, LP, Warren Lowell Putnam & Brynn Jinnett Putnam, Tenants in Common, TriplePoint Ventures 5 LLC, Embedfi June 2021, a Series of Party Round LLC, TriplePoint Venture Lending Fund, LLC, Joe Percoco, Clayton Gardner, Kick the Hive LLC, Stephen Harper, Samuel Jones, Jonathan Duarte, Christian Nordby, Christopher Harper, Paul Trone, Matthew Lyon, and Transpose Platform Fintech Fund II, L.P. at the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware.

Alameda Research Ltd. et al v. Rocket Internet Capital Partners II SCS et al: Complaint (‘$6.9M Fraudulent Transfers’)

May 17, 2023
Complaint in Alameda Research Ltd., of the British Virgin Islands; West Realm Shires Inc., and West Realm Shires Services Inc., both of Delaware v. Rocket Internet Capital Partners II SCS, Rocket Internet Capital Partners (Euro) II SCS, GFC Global Founders Capital GmbH, GFC Global Founders Capital GmbH & Co., Beteiligungs KG Nr. 1, William Hockey Living Trust, and 9Yards Capital Investments II LP at the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware.

GeoSolutions BV et al v. Sina Corporation et al: Second Amended Complaint (‘Fraud’)

May 16, 2023
Complaint alleging "the misappropriation of GeoSolutions' valuable technology and know-how relating to the use of location-based services to enhance and monetize social networking services" in GeoSolutions B.V. and GeoSolutions Holdings N.V., both of the Netherlands v. Sina Corporation, described as a Cayman Islands-domiciled, China-based holding company that is "self-described as 'a leading online media company serving China the global Chinese communities'"; Weibo Corporation, described as being domiciled in the Cayman Islands and based in China; SINA.COM Online, Weibo R&D Limited, New Wave MMXV Ltd., described as being domiciled in the British Virgin Islands and based in China; Sina Group Holding Company Ltd., described as being domiciled in the Cayman Islands and based in China; Sina Hong Kong Limited, of Hong Kong; GyPSii (Shanghai) Co., Ltd., of China; Beijing Sina Internet Information Service Company Ltd., of China; Beijing New Media Technology Information Company, of China; Beijing Weimeng Technology Co., Ltd., of China; Sina (Beijing) Information Technology Co. Ltd. of China; SINA.COM Technology (China) Co., Ltd., of China; Cao Guowei, a.k.a. Chao Guowei, a.k.a. Charles Chao, of China, and Wang Gaofei, of China, at the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.

Vantage Mezzanine Fund II Partnership v. The Clearing House Payments Company LLC et al: Discovery Application (Bermuda, Italy & Malta)

May 5, 2023
Application by Vantage Mezzanine Fund II Partnership, described as a South African "investment fund that provides finance to high-risk businesses across Africa and in other developing jurisdictions", to take discovery from The Clearing House Payments Company LLC, Barclays Bank PLC, Citibank N.A., Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas, HSBC Bank USA, N.A., JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., The Bank of New York Mellon, The Northern Trust Company, f.k.a. The Northern Trust International Banking Corporation; UBS AG, and Wells Fargo Bank N.A. for use in legal proceedings in Bermuda, Italy, and Malta to enforce an arbitration award of US$59.4 million "against Mr. John Eric Kodwo Taylor", who was described as a citizen of Ghana and Malta and "executive chairperson of Surfline Communications Ltd., a Ghanaian company engaged in developing high-speed internet networks in Ghana", at the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

National Bank Trust PJSC v. Mikail Shishkhanov et al: Claim Form (‘$2B Rost Bank Fraud’)

May 4, 2023
Claim Form to recover "damages in excess of USD$2 billion which were suffered by its legal predecessor, JSC "ROST BANK", as a result of a series of sham transactions" in National Bank Trust PJSC v. Mikail Osmanovich Shishkhanov, of Russia; Crambe Asset Holdings Corp. (in liquidation), Olyserve Inc. (in liquidation), Rabalo Limited (in liquidation), Reachway Overseas Ltd. (in liquidation), Ifichor S.A. (in liquidation), formerly Hansberg Finance Ltd.; Frowell Holdings Ltd. (in liquidation), Garland Solutions Ltd. (in liquidation), Diamond Forca Ltd. (in liquidation), Darman Finance Limited (in liquidation), Blanche Union Ltd. (in liquidation), all of the British Virgin Islands; Midwestern Trading Group Inc., of Minnesota, USA; Cargill Financial Solutions LLC, of Minnesota, USA; Cargill Inc., of Delaware, USA; Bunge SA, of Switzerland; Credit and Trading Company Ltd.,, of England; Quadra Commodities SA, of Switzerland; Quadra Commodities Singapore Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; Louis Dreyfus Company Suisse SA, of Switzerland; LDC Trading and Service Co. S.A., of Uruguay; Louis Dreyfus Company Asia Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; New Resources International S.A. (in liquidation), formerly Noble Resources International S.A., of Switzerland; Liberty Commodities Limited, of England; Atlantic Industrial & Trading Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; Alphatrade International Limited, of Hong Kong; Xangbo Global Markets Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; Simec Group Limited, of Hong Kong; Wilson International Trading Private Limited, of Singapore; Intra Asia Trading Pte. Ltd. (in liquidation), of Singapore; Triumph Commodities Pte. Ltd., formerly Triumph Metals & Minerals Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; Bering Trading Limited, of Hong Kong; Ifchor (Switzerland) SA, formerly Ifchor SA, of Switzerland; Emporium Trade Pte. Ltd., formerly Pan Asia Commodities and Trading Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; Paras Metallics Pte. Ltd., of Singapore; Pearl River Delta Trading (Hong Kong) Limited, of Hong Kong, and Credit Suisse AG, of Switzerland, at the British Virgin Islands High Court.

Kevin Kang v. BKCoin Management LLC et al: Complaint (‘$100M Crypto Fraud Indemnification’)

May 2, 2023
Complaint "to obtain an order compelling Goldberg to honor BKCoin Capital LP and BKCoin’s contractual obligations to Kang, indemnify Kang, and advance him expenses that he has incurred and will incur going forward under the Amended LP Agreement" in Kevin Kang v. BKCoin Management LLC, BKCoin Capital LP, and Michael Goldberg at the U.. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Todd Smith et al v. Grok Management LLC et al: Complaint (‘$350K Investment Loss’)

May 1, 2023
Complaint in Todd Smith and Lisa Smith, individually and derivatively on behalf of Grok Algo LP, of Delaware, and Grok Global Ltd., d.b.a. Grok Global LP, of the British Virgin Islands v. Grok Management LLC, of Delaware, and Des Woodruff, as Defendants, and Grok Algo LP, of Delaware, and Grok Global LP, of the British Virgin Islands, as Nominal Defendants, at the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida.

Sam Allardyce et al v. Fat Cat Films Ltd.: Liquidation Application (‘£51.8M Debt’)

April 28, 2023
Originating Application in Michael Ward, Christopher Carpmael, Philip Stephen Bradley, Mike Hilton, Timothy Attias, Edward Bowen, Andrew Crane, Ray Davis, Mark Dormer, Kimbell Duncan, Tim Gledhill, John Goodridge, Bruce Hanton, Adam Hart, Mark Hobbs, Matthew Holland, Jeremy Isaacs, Glenn Jones, Tracey Jones, Tiina Lee, Jon Macintosh, Jason Mackay, Simon Meadows, Derek Mills, Eric Nicoli, John Nixon, Christopher Anthony Roads, Casper Shand-Kydd, Declan Walsh, Sam Allardyce, Kenan Altunis, Bryan Beeston, Graeme Blakey, EAM Boscawen, Andrew Boulton, John Brooksbank, Michael Coatman, Rick Corne, Peter Cowgill, The Earl of Derby, Elke Edwards, Robert Tregellas Elliott, Eric Entwistle, Gary Entwistle, Lorne Entwistle, Andrew Nicholas Gaskell, Martin Gavin, Michel Glas, Julie Green-Jones, Peter Horsman, Roger Humber, Nick Kelsey, Stephen Lister, Ross McDonald, Marc Middleton, Kevin Ohle, Raymond O'Leary, Charles Patchett, Michael Patchett, Peter Reid, David Renshaw, Russell Mark Roberts, Philip Robert-Tissot, Gordon Stephenson, David Stoller, Lee Stoller, Bernhard Weninger, John Ambery, Julian Beressi, Warren Briggs, Mark Cherry, Mike Cutler, Christopher Dale, Scott Harrison, Steve Jennings, Stephen Kingston, Richard Lewis, J.R. Lister, Fabrizio Pagani, Geoffrey Reid, Simon Ashworth, Ben Britz, Anthony Burling, Gavin Davidson-Merritt, Evan Huw Davies, Stephen Down, Nigel Higgins, Andrew Hill, Jacqueline E.S. Hoyland, John Nicolas Jeremy Hoyland, Byron Hurst, Ross K. Hyett, Brian Jones, Dr. Sonil Kalia, Daniel Kerven, Surrinder Kumar, Robert Leitao, Robert Meakin, Michael Moss, Timothy Francis Xavier Parr, Charles Pelham, Mark R. Perowne, Douglas Rae, Peter Sharpe, John Shepherd, Thomas Peter Tidy, and John Willis v. Fat Cat Films Limited at the British Virgin Islands High Court.

Commercial Bank of Dubai v. Mohamed Abdalla Juma Al-Sari et al: Fixed Date Claim Form

April 26, 2023
Fixed Date Claim Form for the appointment of a Receiver over shares in the two corporate defendants in Commercial Bank of Dubai v. Mohamed Abdalla Juma Al-Sari, Majid Abdalla Juma Al-Sari, both of Sharjah, United Arab Emirates; Layyah Holdings Limited, and Majid Investments Limited at the British Virgin Islands High Court.

Diversified Real Estate Development Ltd. et al v. Deutsche Bank AG et al: Judgment ($95M)

April 26, 2023
Judgment for $95 million in Michael Pearson, Andrew Childe and Anna Silver, all of FFP, on behalf of and solely in their capacities as Joint Official Liquidators of Diversified Real Estate Development Ltd. (in Official Liquidation), GMS Global Market Step Up Note Ltd. (in Official Liquidation), Preferred Income Collateralized Interest Ltd. (in Official Liquidation), Sentinel Investment Fund SPC (in Official Liquidation), SG Strategic Income Ltd. (in Official Liquidation), Sports Aficionados Ltd. (in Official Liquidation), Vanguardia Group Inc. (in Official Liquidation), and Michael Pearson, on behalf of and solely in his capacity as Liquidator of Sentinel Mandate and Escrow Ltd. (in Liquidation), Vanguardia Holdings Ltd. (in Liquidation), Spyglass Investment Management Ltd. (in Liquidation), North Pointe Holdings (BVI) Ltd. (in Liquidation), Biscayne Capital Holdings Limited (in Creditor Voluntary Liquidation), and Biscayne Capital (B.V.I.) Ltd. (in Liquidation) v. Deutsche Bank AG, Deutsche Bank Luxembourg S.A., Deutsche Bank Switzerland, and Deutsche Bank Trust Companies Americas at the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

Wikeley Family Trustee Ltd.: Chapter 15 Petition (New Zealand)

April 20, 2023
Chapter 15 Petition for Recognition of a Foreign Main Proceeding in New Zealand by Brendon Gibson and Natalie Burrett, as the Foreign Representatives of Wikeley Family Trustee Limited, described as "the trustee of the Wikeley Family Trust", filed at the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky.

Catherine St. Jean v. Richard Branson et al: Complaint (‘Insider Trading’)

April 19, 2023
Stockholder Derivative Complaint alleging breach of fiduciary duty by insider trading and unjust enrichment in Catherine St. Jean v. Richard Branson, described as a citizen of the British Virgin Islands; Michelle Kley, Craig Kreeger, and Chamath Palihapitiya, as Defendants, and Virgin Galactic Holdings Inc., as Nominal Defendant, at the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York.

Axtra LLC et al v. AXIA Issuer Inc. et al: Amended Complaint (‘Crypto Fraud’)

April 17, 2023
Amended Complaint alleging "a scheme to defraud Plaintiffs and other potential investors by a collection of sophisticated international entities and individuals through the operation of a cryptocurrency project" in Axtra LLC, of Wyoming, and The AXIA-Axtra Trust, described as “a unit trust formed under the laws of the Cayman Islands” v. AXIA Issuer Inc., of the British Virgin Islands; AXIA Foundation Inc., described as “purportedly a not-for-profit entity governed under the laws of the Commonwealth of Dominica”, and Berkower LLC, of New Jersey, at the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming.

Marc Chan et al v. ArcSoft Inc. et al: Third Amended Complaint (‘Securities Fraud’)

April 4, 2023
Third Amended Complaint alleging securities fraud in Marc Chan, a citizen of Canada; Lei Li, of Hong Kong; Strong Wealth Investment Limited, of the British Virgin Islands, and Pacific Smile Limited, of the British Virgin Islands v. ArcSoft Inc., described as "a software company whose primary business is licensing software and algorithms to the manufacturers of smartphones and consumer electronics", and Michael Deng at the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.

Virgin Orbit Holdings Inc. et al: Chapter 11 Petition

April 4, 2023
Chapter 11 Petition by Virgin Orbit Holdings Inc., JACM Holdings inc., Vieco USA Inc., Virgin Orbit LLC, and Virgin Orbit National Systems LLC, filed at the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware.

BTA Bank v. ADM Trade Resources Inc.: Receivership Petition

April 3, 2023
Petition for the Appointment of a Receiver for ADM Trade Resources Inc. in BTA Bank, of Kazakhstan v. ADM Trade Resources Inc., formerly known as ADM-ACTI Trade Resources, Inc., at the Court of Chancery of the State of Delaware.

Sahara Oil and Gas v. Cheiron Holdings Egypt Ltd. et al: Writ of Summons

March 31, 2023
Writ of Summons and General Indorsement involving shares in Sahara North Bahariya Limited, of the Cayman Islands, in Sahara Oil and Gas, of Egypt v. Cheiron Holdings Egypt Ltd., Cheiron Western Desert Limited, and Cheiron Finance Limited, all of the British Virgin Islands, at the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands.

Adenium Energy Capital Ltd. v. Viscom Investments Ltd. et al: Writ of Summons

March 30, 2023
Writ of Summons and General Indorsement in Christopher Kennedy and Alexander Lawson, as Joint Official Liquidators for and on behalf of Adenium Energy Capital Ltd. (in Official Liquidation) v. Viscom Investments Ltd., of the Bahamas; Infinity World Investments SA, of Panama; Maymouna Holding SAL, of the Republic of Lebanon; Wassef Sawaf, of Dubai, United Arab Emirates, and KSB Capital (Offshore) SAL, of the Republic of Lebanon, at the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands.

PJSC Platinum Bank: Chapter 15 Petition (Ukraine)

March 29, 2023
Chapter 15 Petition for Recognition of a Foreign Main Proceeding in Ukraine by Victor Novikov, as the Foreign Representative of PJSC Platinum Bank, described as "an insolvent Ukrainian bank", at the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Florida.

Nano Dimension Ltd. v. Murchinson Ltd. et al: Complaint (‘Securities Fraud’)

March 27, 2023
Complaint alleging a "scheme to manipulate the public trading of Nano's stock in violation of U.S. securities laws" by "consortium of hedge fund short-sellers" in Nano Dimension Ltd., described as "an Israel-based manufacturer with operations in Israel, the United States, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and Australia" v. Murchinson Ltd., of Canada; EOM Management Ltd., of Bermuda; Nomis Bay Ltd., of Bermuda; BPY Limited, of Bermuda; Anson Advisors Inc., of Canada; Anson Funds Management LP, of Texas, USA; Anson Management GP LLC, of Texas, USA; Boothbay Fund Management LLC, of New York, USA; Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies LP, of Delaware, and Boothbay Diversified Alpha Master Fund LP, of New York, at the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Measure 8 Ventures LP et al v. Nitin Khanna et al: Complaint (‘Securities Fraud’)

March 24, 2023
Complaint alleging securities fraud in Measure 8 Ventures LP, Gron Ventures Fund I LP, Zola Global Investors Ltd., of the British Virgin Islands; Anson Advisors Inc., of Canada, on behalf of Anson East Master Fund LP, AC Anson Investments Ltd., Anson Investments Master Fund LP, and Anson Opportunities Master Fund LP; Serendipity SPC – Trimble Fund SP, of the Cayman Islands, on behalf of Emerald Spur Limited; Lapid US Investments LLC, and Hadron Healthcare and Consumer Special Opportunities Master Fund, of the Cayman Islands v. Nitin Khanna, Karan Khanna, Angelo Lombardi, Sam Knapp, David Thompson, Nicholas J. Slinde, Benjamin C. Stoller, and Allan Goodman, of Canada, at the Supreme Court of the State of New York, County of New York.

Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd. et al v. Jardine Strategic Holdings Ltd. et al: Appeal Judgment

March 24, 2023
Judgment in Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd., Attestor Value Master Fund LP, Maso Capital Investments Limited, Star V Partners LLC, Blackwell Partners LLC - Series A, Citco Trustees (Cayman) Limited, as Trustee of the Allard Growth Fund; DMS UCITS Platform ICAV, on behalf of its sub-fund, Allard Asia UCITS Fund; Allard Partners Australia Pty Limited, as Trustee of the Allard Investment Fund; Alpine Partner (BVI) LP, acting through its General Partner, Alpine Global Management LLC; 405 ACM Ltd., Athos Special situations Fund SPC, on behalf of its segregated account, Athos Global Opportunities SP-1; FMAP ACL Limited, Athos Asia Event Driven Master Fund, Citadel Equity Fund Ltd., C+F NV, Portus NV, Value Square Fund NV, Cedar SA, AVI Global Trust Plc, Norges Bank, Wakeland Securities LP, Wakefield Securities LLC, FourWorld Global Opportunities Fund Ltd., FourWorld Event Opportunities LP, Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies LP, Boothbay Diversified Alpha Master Fund LP, Integrated Core Strategies (Asia) Pte Ltd., PWCM Master Fund Ltd., Pentwater Equity Opportunities Master Fund Ltd., Pentwater Merger Arbitrage Master Fund Ltd., Crown Managed Accounts SPC, Pentwater Metric Merger Arbitrage Fund LP, through its General Partner, Pentwater Metric Merger Arbitrage CP LLC; Pentwater Unconstrained Master Fund Ltd., Helium Fund, on behalf of its sub-funds, Helijm Selection and Helium Performance; Helium Opportunities, Merlin Fidelis Emerging Markets Fund, Hildene Opportunities Master Fund II Limited, Stonehill Master Fund Ltd., Stonehill Institutional Partners LP, APS Holdings Corporation, Sunrise Partners Limited Partnership, The Funicular Fund LP, Shay Capital LLC, One68 Global Master Fund LP, Golden Chance Goldsmith Pte Ltd., Qube Master Fund Ltd., QRT Master Fund SPC - Torus Fund SP; Lakeville Capital Investors (enhanced) Master Limited, Lakeville Capital Investors Limited, Prelude Opportunity Fund LP, Davidson Kempner Partners, M.H. Davidson & Co., Davidson Kempner International Ltd., Davidson Kempner Institutional Partners LP. Schonfeld IR Master Fund Pte Ltd., Schonfeld Global Master Fund LP, Samson Rock Event Driven Master Fund Limited, Pictet TR - Diversified Alpha, Alphanatics Master Fuind Limited, Indus Select Master Fund Ltd., Vitruvius - Asian Equity, a sub-fund of Vitruvius SICAV; Cambridge University Endowment Fund, FMI International Fund, FMI International Fund II - Currency Unhedged, Man Funds XII SPC-Man 1783 II SP, Man GLG Credit Multi Strategy Master Fund, Graham Leigh Collins, Beral Holdings Pte Ltd., Wong Hong Yen, Hong Sun Wong, Clifford Cheah King Mun, Stephanie Vanessa Ling-Tsu Cheah, Albert Neo Po Soon, Lau Mei Leng, The Gabelli Small Cap Growth Fund, The Gabelli Equity Income Fund, The Gabelli Asset Fund, Gabelli Associates Limited, Gabelli Associates Fund, Gabelli Associates Ltd. II E, The Gabelli Multimedia Trust Inc., GGCP Inc., Gabelli Associates Fund II LP, The Gabelli Global Rising Income and Dividend Fund, The Gabelli Global Global Utility & Income Trust, The Gabelli Equity Trust Inc., The Gabelli Dividend and Income Trust, Gabelli Arbitrage Holdings, and Gabelli Global Small and Mid Cap Value Trust v. Jardine Strategic Holdings Limited and Jardine Strategic Limited at Bermuda Court of Appeal.